The excess insurance market faces major upheaval in 2026 as global carriers adapt to sweeping regulatory, economic, and capacity shifts. According to the IAIS 2024 report, global reinsurance premiums reached about US$900 billion by the end of 2023. This highlights the growing scale and complexity of risk transfer across the industry.
At the same time, the 2025 Aon Global Insurance Market Insights show a wave of premium reductions across many insurance lines. The report also highlights abundant capacity, including in the excess insurance market.
These combined trends force both insurers and buyers to reassess attachment points, coverage layers, and underwriting strategies to stay protected.
Regulatory Changes Redefining Excess Insurance Requirements
Deloitte’s 2026 Global Insurance Outlook highlights that insurers entering the next cycle face rising operational complexity. This is driven by economic uncertainty, digital risk, climate exposure, and evolving customer expectations. These forces are pushing regulators to place a sharper focus on risk governance, transparency, and financial resilience.
As regulatory expectations tighten around capital strength, enterprise risk management, and data controls, excess insurers must apply greater discipline. This shift directly affects underwriting standards and portfolio design. For policyholders, this translates into stricter documentation requirements, deeper risk evaluations, and more selective capacity deployment.
Excess insurance placement in 2026 is therefore expected to reflect heightened compliance demands, stronger emphasis on underlying risk quality, and closer alignment between regulatory expectations and coverage structure as outlined in Deloitte’s industry outlook.
Economic Pressures Influencing Pricing and Risk Appetite
Economic pressures continue to shape pricing discipline and risk appetite across the insurance excess market. Inflation-driven claims costs, rising legal expenses, and volatility in catastrophic losses are forcing insurers to reassess how risk is priced and layered.
As underwriting margins tighten, carriers are becoming more selective about the industries and exposures they support. This shift is especially visible in excess workers’ compensation programs. As Prescient National explains, excess coverage steps in when claims exceed a set dollar threshold. It protects employers from both catastrophic losses and unexpected claim frequency.
In periods of economic uncertainty, this protection becomes even more critical. However, it also drives higher pricing, tighter terms, and stricter underwriting standards as insurers balance profitability with long-term sustainability.
Carrier Capacity and Market Competition Trends
WTW’s Insurance Marketplace Realities 2026 report indicates that the commercial insurance market is entering a phase of relative stability. This shift is supported by strong levels of industry capital and healthy reinsurance availability. This improved capacity has increased competition across many insurance lines, giving buyers more leverage during renewals.
However, WTW also highlights that excess casualty and high-limit liability remain exceptions to this broader softening trend. Capacity in these segments continues to be selective, with carriers maintaining disciplined underwriting standards.
As a result, while more insurers are competing for well-managed risks, accounts with higher exposure still face tighter terms and closer scrutiny. For insurance excess buyers in 2026, market conditions will favor strong risk profiles rather than broad concessions.
Changing Coverage Structures and Attachment Points
Coverage structures in the excess insurance market are being reshaped by the rapid escalation of large-loss verdicts in the United States. A Financial Times report highlighted a sharp rise in so-called “nuclear verdicts.” The average corporate jury award climbed to $65.7 million last year, up from $41.7 million in 2023. In total, businesses faced more than $40 billion in damages payments.
This surge in claim severity is pushing insurers to raise attachment points. It is also leading them to tighten lower excess layers and restructure coverage towers to limit early exposure.
As a result, companies are now carrying higher self-insured retention and facing narrower terms. In 2026, buying excess coverage will increasingly depend on strong loss controls and detailed risk profiling.
What These Shifts Mean for Brokers and Policyholders
Regulatory pressure, economic volatility, and carrier discipline are reshaping how excess insurance programs are negotiated in 2026. Brokers will need stronger data quality and more detailed underwriting submissions to secure competitive capacity.
Earlier renewal planning will become standard as markets grow more selective. Policyholders can no longer rely on favorable market cycles alone to achieve better pricing. Strong risk management and clean loss histories will carry greater weight in renewal outcomes.
Higher attachment points will continue to shift more risk onto insured organizations. Selective carrier appetite will require tighter broker and client coordination. Long-term program stability will matter more than short-term premium savings. Preparation, transparency, and consistency will define successful excess placements in 2026.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will small businesses be affected by excess insurance changes in 2026?
Yes, small businesses will be affected by excess insurance changes in 2026. Higher attachment points, selective carrier capacity, and stricter underwriting will make excess coverage harder to access. It may also become more expensive, especially for firms with limited risk controls or loss history.
Can excess insurance still be customized in a tighter market?
Yes, excess insurance can still be customized in a tighter market, but with more limits. Customization now depends heavily on strong risk profiles, detailed underwriting data, and clear loss histories. There are fewer flexible terms and more selective carrier participation in a tighter market.
How can companies prepare financially for stricter excess underwriting?
Companies can prepare by strengthening cash reserves, improving loss control programs, maintaining clean financial records, and investing in risk mitigation. Early budgeting for higher retentions and premiums, along with close coordination with brokers, also helps financially prepare for stricter excess underwriting.
Preparing for a More Disciplined Excess Insurance Market
The excess insurance landscape in 2026 will be defined by tighter regulation, economic pressure, and disciplined carrier behavior. Higher attachment points, selective capacity, and stricter underwriting will become the new normal.
For both brokers and policyholders, success will depend on early planning, strong risk controls, and transparent underwriting data. Companies that invest in loss prevention, clean financial reporting, and proactive broker collaboration will be best positioned to secure stable excess coverage.
In this evolving market, preparation will matter more than timing, and risk quality will outweigh pricing alone.
Also Read : How Disability Claims Navigate the Challenges of Insurance Benefits
